If you’re looking to hire a voice actor for your project, pay to play (P2P) platforms like Voices dot com, Voice123, and Bodalgo may seem like an easy solution. These platforms promise access to a wide range of talent and quick results, but there are significant downsides that clients often don’t realize. Here’s why these platforms might not deliver the best results for your voice over needs and why you should consider alternative ways to hire professional talent.
What Are Pay to Play Platforms and How Do They Work?
P2P platforms work on a subscription basis. Voice actors pay a membership fee to create profiles and audition for projects. On the surface, this seems like a simple and efficient way to connect clients and talent. However, the reality is often very different, with hidden issues that can impact the quality of the talent you’ll find and the overall success of your project.
The Downsides of Pay to Play Voice Over Platforms and Better Alternatives.
Voices dot com
Voices dot com is one of the biggest P2P platforms, but it has raised many ethical concerns in the voice over industry.
• Unfair Budget Practices: Voices dot com acts as an agent, taking a significant 25% cut of your budget. There have even been claims of budget manipulation, where the platform lists a much lower budget to voice actors than what the client originally allocated. For example, if you provide $5,000 for a project, voice actors might only see $1,000 listed. This lack of transparency can lead to frustration for both clients and talent.
• No Direct Connection to Talent: When you hire through Voices dot com, you’ll never get direct contact with the voice actor who audition. You will be able to communicate with the one voice talent you eventually hire. But you won't get that voice actors' email address, phone number, and other details. If they ever decide to move off the platform, you won't be able to find them back for pick-ups or projects where you want to hire the same voice.
Why Bodalgo Might Not Be Ideal for Clients
Bodalgo is known for being ethical in the sense that it doesn’t take a cut from talent fees, but it’s not without its flaws.
• Overwhelming Auditions: Bodalgo connects you with a lot of voice actors, which may sound like a good thing. However, this often results in receiving hundreds of auditions for a single project, most of which don’t match the tone or quality you’re looking for. Sorting through these submissions can be overwhelming and time-consuming.
• Lack of Curated Talent: Because Bodalgo allows a wide range of talent to audition, you’re likely to receive submissions from less experienced voice actors, which can dilute the quality of options you have to choose from.
Voice123’s Popularity Game Isn’t Working for You
Voice123's platform design has its own challenges.
• Pay-to-Play Priority: Voice123’s ranking system prioritizes talent that pays for higher-tier memberships. This means you’re not necessarily getting the best voice actors for your project, but rather those who have paid the most to be seen. Some of the top-tier talent on the platform might not even audition for your project because they’ve become disillusioned with the system.
• Lower Talent Quality: Voice actors on Voice123 often compete for likes and reviews, creating a system that doesn’t necessarily highlight skill or professionalism. For clients, this means you may miss out on highly qualified talent simply because they aren't paying the high membership fees and don’t engage with the platform’s popularity game.
What Does This Mean for Your Voice Over Project?
When you hire through P2P platforms, you risk not getting the best talent for your budget. Between unethical practices, overwhelming numbers of auditions, and pay-to-play prioritization, these platforms often don’t live up to their promises. You may end up with subpar results, wasted time, and even frustration with the hiring process.
What’s the Alternative?
Instead of relying on P2P platforms, consider these alternatives to pay to play voice over platforms to find the best voice actor for your project:
• Direct Outreach: Search for professional voice actors online, on LinkedIn, or through their personal websites. Most experienced talent have easy-to-navigate websites where you can listen to demos and contact them directly.
• Voice Over Agencies: Partner with a reputable voice over agency, such as Voice Over For The Planet. Agencies have curated rosters of talent and can help you find the perfect match for your project, saving you time and effort.
• Referrals and Recommendations: Ask colleagues or industry peers for recommendations. Many voice actors rely on word of mouth, and a referral is often a sign of high-quality talent.
Conclusion: Skip the Pay to Play Platforms for Better Results
While pay to play platforms like Voices dot com, Voice123, and Bodalgo may seem convenient, they come with significant downsides that can hurt the success of your project. From unethical budget practices to prioritizing pay-to-play rankings over actual talent, these platforms often fall short of delivering the quality and professionalism you deserve.
By working directly with voice actors or reputable agencies, you’ll have greater control over the hiring process, access to top-tier talent, and a smoother overall experience. Make the investment in quality, your project and your audience will thank you.
Comentarios